
LHC Acquits Death-Row Prisoner Nasir Ali After Six YearsPakistan
A two-member Lahore High Court bench set aside Nasir Ali’s death sentence, ruling the prosecution could not prove its witnesses were at the crime scene and their accounts contradicted each other.

The Lahore High Court has acquitted Nasir Ali, a prisoner sentenced to death in a murder case, six years after his conviction, allowing his appeal and setting aside the death sentence, Dunya News reported on Monday.
A two-member bench comprising Justice Shahram Sarwar Chaudhry and Justice Sardar Akbar Ali Dogar announced the verdict on the prisoner’s appeal.
The court observed that the prosecution had failed to establish the presence of witnesses at the crime scene, while inconsistencies were also found in their statements. On these grounds, the court ordered Nasir Ali’s acquittal.
The court subsequently set aside the death sentence awarded to Nasir Ali in the murder case and accepted his appeal.
It may be recalled that Sadar Hafizabad Police had registered a murder case over the killing of Jahangir.
In murder cases, a death sentence handed down by a trial court is subject to confirmation by the high court, and the convict has the right to appeal. In cases carrying the death penalty, the prosecution is required to prove its case beyond reasonable doubt, and contradictions in the evidence generally go in favour of the accused.
The same two-judge bench had acquitted two men, Abid and Haq Nawaz, in a separate murder case last week, setting aside a trial court verdict that had sentenced one of them to death and the other to life imprisonment, The News reported. In that case, the bench found contradictions between the medical report and the statements of eyewitnesses. The accused had been charged with murdering Ghulam Mustafa and injuring six others over previous civil litigation, with a case registered at Shorkot City Police Station in Jhang district in June 2021.
The high court hears appeals against convictions handed down by trial courts across Punjab, and its two-member benches regularly decide appeals in murder cases, where the evidence of eyewitnesses is tested against the medical and forensic record. Where the prosecution’s account is found wanting, the court may set aside the conviction and order the release of the appellant.
The verdict underlines the courts’ insistence on consistent and credible evidence in cases carrying the death penalty, where the prosecution must establish its case beyond reasonable doubt.






